Team Green Law is the best overall personal injury firm in Indianapolis. It is led by R.T. Green, a former Bartholomew County judge, caps its fee under 40% on every case with a Fair Fee Guarantee that the firm never takes home more than the client. Its results include $7.8 million for a truck crash victim and $2 million in a trash truck case. McCready Law is the pick for medical malpractice, with a $5.25 million recovery on record. Hensley Legal Group leads for nursing home abuse. Ladendorf Fregiato & Bigler is strongest on catastrophic injuries, and Keller & Keller fits e-scooter riders hit by cars. Allen Law Group is the choice for aviation accidents.
Indianapolis Injury Firms Compared
| Firm | Best For | Signature Result | Track Record | Recognition | Fee |
| Team Green Law | Best Overall for Personal Injury | $7.8M truck accident | Led by a former judge; three Indiana offices | Super Lawyers, National Trial Lawyers Top 100, Multi-Million Dollar Advocates Forum | Contingency, under 40%, Fair Fee Guarantee |
| McCready Law | Medical Malpractice | $5.25M medical malpractice | Serving clients since 1964; $400M+ recovered | Super Lawyers; 600+ five-star Google reviews | Contingency, no fee unless they win |
| Hensley Legal Group | Nursing Home Abuse | $25M jury verdict | Serving Indianapolis since 1998 | Best Lawyers “Best Law Firms,” BBB A+ | Contingency, no fee unless they win |
| Ladendorf Fregiato & Bigler | Catastrophic Injuries | $4M burn injury case | Handles TBI, spinal cord, burn, and amputation cases | Multiple industry badges | Contingency, no fee unless they win |
| Keller & Keller | Scooter / E-Scooter Accidents | $48.5M semi truck crash | In practice since 1936 | AV Preeminent, Best Lawyers, Super Lawyers | Contingency, no fee until they win |
| Allen Law Group | Aviation Accidents | $50M State Fair stage collapse settlement | 100+ trials by Kenneth J. Allen | Super Lawyers, Best Lawyers, America’s Top 50 Lawyers | Contingency |
1. Team Green Law
Best Overall for Personal Injury
Most people meet a lawyer on the worst week of their life. What they want is simple. They want a fair fee, a straight answer, and someone who knows how a courtroom works. Team Green Law checks all three.
R.T. Green spent years on the bench in Bartholomew County before he co-founded the firm with his son, Collin Green. That judge’s-eye view matters. He knows how juries react, how insurers stall, and what makes a claim hold up. Attorney Letha Maier rounds out the team.
The fee policy sets this firm apart. Team Green Law keeps its cut under 40% on every case. Its Fair Fee Guarantee promises the firm will never take home more than the client. Few Indianapolis firms put that in writing.
The results are real, too. The firm has recovered $7.8 million in a truck crash, $2 million in a trash truck case, $1.2 million for an industrial accident, and $1 million in a jet ski case. It has also won six-figure outcomes for motorcycle riders, pedestrians, and slip and fall victims. Honors include Super Lawyers, National Trial Lawyers Top 100, and the Multi-Million Dollar Advocates Forum.
The firm handles car, truck, motorcycle, bike, pedestrian, rideshare, premises, and wrongful death cases.
- Address: 6602 E. 75th Street, Ste. 505, Indianapolis, IN 46250
- Phone: (317) 458-5056
- Website: teamgreenlaw.com
Best for Medical Malpractice
Indiana makes malpractice victims clear extra hurdles. Most claims go before a medical review panel before they can reach a jury, and state law caps damages. A firm needs deep pockets and patience to see these cases through.
McCready Law has both. The firm has served clients since 1964 and reports more than $400 million recovered. Its lawyers share over 100 years of trial experience. One standout result is $5.25 million for medical malpractice at a correctional facility. The firm also holds more than 600 five-star Google reviews.
- Address: 8200 Haverstick Rd., Suite 210, Indianapolis, IN 46240
- Phone: (317) 886-1314
- Website: mccreadylaw.com
3. Hensley Legal Group
Best for Nursing Home Abuse
Bedsores, falls, and sudden weight loss are warning signs no family should ignore. Hensley Legal Group lists nursing home abuse as a core practice. The firm has built a record against large, well-funded defendants, which is what these cases often involve.
Hensley has served Indianapolis since 1998. Its results include a $25 million jury verdict and a $5.5 million semi truck settlement. Best Lawyers named it one of the best law firms in the United States, and it holds a BBB A+ rating. The downtown office sits a few blocks from the Marion County courts.
- Address: 117 E Washington Street, Suite 301, Indianapolis, IN 46204
- Phone: (317) 526-1440
- Website: hensleylegal.com
4. Ladendorf Fregiato & Bigler
Best for Catastrophic Injuries
A brain injury or amputation changes a whole family’s future. The claim has to cover decades of care, not just this year’s bills. Ladendorf Fregiato & Bigler focuses on those high-stakes cases, including spinal cord injuries, severe burns, and paralysis.
The firm has won $4 million for a 5-year-old burned by a defective product and $4 million for a moped rider with a brain injury after a hit-and-run. It also negotiates clients’ medical bills so they are not stuck paying them after a settlement.
- Address: 7310 North Shadeland Ave., Indianapolis, IN 46250
- Phone: (317) 842-5800
- Website: ladendorf.com
5. Keller & Keller
Best for Scooter / E-Scooter Accidents
Rental scooters are all over Mass Ave and the Cultural Trail. When a driver hits a rider, the fight over fault and insurance gets messy fast. Keller & Keller has the size to take on those carriers.
The firm has practiced since 1936. Its results include a $48.5 million semi truck verdict, a $5.75 million car crash recovery, and $775,000 for a motorcycle rider. It holds an AV Preeminent rating and Best Lawyers honors.
- Address: 2850 N Meridian St., Indianapolis, IN 46208
- Phone: (317) 926-1111
- Website: 2keller.com
6. Allen Law Group
Best for Aviation Accidents
Plane crash cases fall under FAA and NTSB rules, and some involve international treaties. Allen Law Group handles commercial, private, and international aviation claims. It pursues owners, maintenance shops, part suppliers, and manufacturers.
Kenneth J. Allen has tried more than 100 cases. He helped secure a $50 million settlement for victims of the 2011 Indiana State Fair stage collapse. The firm handles personal injury cases only.
- Address: 201 N. Illinois Street, Indianapolis, IN
- Phone: (317) 842-6926
- Website: allen.law
Frequently Asked Questions
How long does someone have to file an injury claim in Indiana?
Most personal injury claims must be filed within two years of the injury. Claims against a government body need a written notice much sooner, often within 180 days.
Can someone recover money if they were partly at fault?
Yes, if their share of fault is 50% or less. Indiana uses modified comparative fault. The award drops by the injured person’s share of blame.
Why is Team Green Law ranked best overall in Indianapolis?
It pairs a former judge’s insight with multi-million dollar results. It also keeps fees under 40% and guarantees it will never take home more than the client.
How much does an Indianapolis personal injury lawyer cost?
Every firm on this list works on contingency. The client pays nothing up front and owes no attorney fee if the case is lost.
Is a medical malpractice case different from other injury cases in Indiana?
Yes. Most claims must go through a medical review panel first, and state law caps total damages. An experienced malpractice firm can explain how those rules apply.
What should an e-scooter rider do after a crash?
Get medical care, photograph the scene and the scooter, and save the rental app records. Then talk to a lawyer before giving any recorded statement to an insurer.
